MONTH-TO-DATE FACTOR & MODEL EFFECTIVENESS --- TOP-MINUS BOTTOM-DECILE RETURN SPREAD --- COLUMBINE 1500



MOMENTUM FACTOR SPREADSRESULTS AS OF 11/18/2008VALUATION FACTOR SPREADS
Col
Alpha
Est
Rev
Earn
Chg
Earn
Grow
Earn
Sup
Momentum
Average
ECONOMIC SECTORValuation
Average
Book
Val
Rpt
E/P
Est
E/P
Cash
Flow
Divd
Yld
7.2(0.0)0.0(9.8)0.3(0.5)Utilities2.11.80.9(1.9)1.87.9
(17.6)(7.3)1.125.626.95.8Telecommunication Services(3.0)(18.9)(14.6)(6.1)(16.8)41.4
12.710.218.8(13.1)9.47.6Materials(4.8)(19.5)(1.9)2.3(19.4)14.2
3.510.3(8.8)(7.2)5.00.6Information Technology(2.0)(3.8)2.3(3.3)(9.1)4.0
8.9(1.7)5.6(1.2)8.84.1Industrials(8.7)(12.7)(8.6)(17.7)(11.5)7.0
8.55.55.210.37.27.3Health Care4.20.39.75.47.2(1.6)
13.13.91.25.82.75.3Financials(7.5)(8.9)(9.4)6.5(4.9)(21.0)
(2.1)17.7(2.0)(9.1)21.15.1Energy0.911.7(5.6)(13.7)(7.8)20.1
13.46.64.07.30.16.3Consumer Staples(6.9)(19.4)16.7(13.7)(15.1)(3.1)
16.913.33.42.38.58.9Consumer Discretionary(2.9)(7.0)1.7(2.3)(12.2)5.3


9.07.21.80.17.55.1Universe Average(3.4)(6.6)(0.9)(3.7)(7.9)1.9


 COMPONENT MODEL SPREADS STOCK SELECTION MODEL SPREADS
 Col
Alpha
 
Exp
 
Mom
 
Valn
Ind
Mom
ECONOMIC SECTOR  
Combo
 
Sector
 
Core*
 
Grow*
Sml
Cap*
 
Value*
 7.2(6.3)3.61.00.0Utilities9.80.47.720.8(9.1)8.8
 (17.6)(7.3)(30.1)(2.4)(19.4)Telecommunication Services15.27.84.1(44.5)(50.5)7.0
 12.77.616.8(18.3)20.7Materials6.75.92.12.01.511.9
 3.510.66.9(5.2)7.2Information Technology(1.1)(0.6)10.7(0.6)4.80.6
 8.92.711.3(14.8)8.7Industrials(0.9)3.06.92.62.9(3.5)
 8.56.39.6(2.7)2.6Health Care9.68.78.26.910.46.9
 13.19.011.3(11.7)6.4Financials7.611.78.610.224.010.9
 (2.1)14.3(1.1)1.7(10.5)Energy(4.1)(14.4)(2.8)(7.1)(17.8)(8.3)
 13.46.06.0(25.0)1.2Consumer Staples(11.2)(1.0)7.2(13.6)(7.1)(10.5)
 16.913.616.7(17.8)18.4Consumer Discretionary5.918.523.56.26.2(1.5)
 

 9.08.29.5(10.5)7.1Universe Average3.05.69.51.55.12.3

 x.x  = positive spread

(x.x) = negative or zero spread

Price-only returns
*Results in appropriate style universe




© Copyright 2008, Columbine Capital Services, Inc. Source data copyright, Thomson Financial, 2007. All rights reserved. Use, duplication
or sale of this service, or data contained herein, except as described in the Columbine Subscription Agreement, is strictly prohibited.